Critical Analysis of Law
An International & Interdisciplinary Law Review
Vol 2, n°2 (2015). - Why Law Matters - Arts and the Aesthetic in Legal History
University of Toronto, Faculty of Law, ISSN:2291-9732
et sommaires des vol. précédents
Présentation
Issue 2:2 includes two forums, and four guest editors. The first forum, on Alon Harel's Why Law Matters (OUP 2014), is guest edited by Vera Bergelson and is based on a 2014 book workshop at Rutgers School of Law-Newark. The second forum, on "Arts and the Aesthetic in Legal History," is guest edited by Roy Kreitner, Anat Rosenberg, and Christopher Tomlins, and originated in a conference at Tel Aviv University in 2014.
Table of Contents
Book Forum: Alon Harel, Why Law Matters (2014)
- Judgment, Communication, and Coercion: What’s Wrong with Private Prisons?, Malcolm Thorburn - PDF
- Facing Terror Together: Public Agents and Civic Worth, Enow Yankah - PDF
- Tragic Choices and the Law, Leo Zaibert - PDF
- Why Law Matters for Our Obligations, Guyora Binder - PDF
- Why Instrumentalism Matter, Kyron Huigens - PDF
- Facing Up: A Response to Critiques of Why Law Matters, Alon Harel - PDF
Special Issue: Arts and the Aesthetic in Legal History
- Arts and the Aesthetic in Legal History, Roy Kreitner, Anat Rosenberg, Christopher Tomlins - PDF
- Art and the History of Environmental Law, David B. Schorr - PDF
- “An Absurdly Quiet Spot”: The Spatial Justice of WW1 Fraternizations, Andreas Philippopoulos-Mihalopoulos - PDF
- The Realism of the Balance Sheet: Value Assessments Between the Debtors Act and The Picture of Dorian Gray, Anat Rosenberg - PDF
- Styron’s Nat: or, The Metaphysics of Presence, Christopher Tomlins - PDF
- Too Much Property, Ravit Reichman - PDF
- The Legal Historian as Detective, Steven Wilf - PDF
- “I Hear No Things Laid to My Charge”: Aurality in Anne Hutchinson’s Trial Transcript, Nan Goodman - PDF
- Transitional Justice as a Modern Oedipus: The Emergence of a Right to Truth, Leora Bilsky - PDF
- Jewish Law, Hasidic Lore, and Hollywood Legend: The Cantor, the Mystic, and the Jurist, Levi Cooper - PDF
- Order in the Archives: The Victorian Art of Legal History, Christine L. Krueger - PDF
- Effect and Technique in Legal Aesthetics, Simon Stern - PDF
CAL's second issue features three forums: two book forums and one article forum. The book forums are inspired by Alan Brudner's The Unity of the Common Law (rev. ed. 2013) and Hanoch Dagan's Reconstructing American Legal Realism & Rethinking Private Law Theory (2013). The article forum features James Q. Whitman's paper "The Case for Penal Modernism: Beyond Utility and Desert," along with comments by Darryl Brown and Lindsay Farmer, as well as a reply by Whitman.
Article Forum: James Q. Whitman on Penal Modernism
- The Case for Penal Modernism: Beyond Utility and Desert, James Q. Whitman - PDF
- Penal Modernism in Theory and Practice, Darryl K. Brown - PDF
- Penal Modernism: An American Tragedy, Lindsay Farmer - PDF
- Response to My Commentators, James Q. Whitman - PDF
Book Forum: Hanoch Dagan, Reconstructing American Legal Realism & Rethinking Private Law Theory (2013)
- Realism’s Illusions, Alan Brudner - PDF
- The Scalpel and the Salve: Rekindling Romantic Realism, Dan Farman - PDF
- Private Law Realism, Joseph William Singer - PDF
- Reality and Illusion, Laura S. Underkuffler - PDF
- Defending Legal Realism: A Response to Four Critics, Hanoch Dagan - PDF
Book Forum: Alan Brudner, The Unity of the Common Law (rev. ed. 2013)
- Liberalism and the Private Law of Property, Hanoch Dagan - PDF
- Tort Law Recovered? From Alan Brudner’s Revised Case for Tort Law to the Ethical Underpinnings of Liberal Democracy, François du Bois - PDF
- Contract and Capitalism for the Philosophical Sophisticate, Roy Kreitner - PDF
- The Dialogic Community at Dusk, Peter Ramsay - PDF
- Uncovering the Latent Disunity of Property Law?, Igor Shoikhedbrod - PDF
- In Defense of Embedded Atomism: A Reply to Critics, Alan Brudner - PDF
Critical Analysis of Law and the New Interdisciplinary
The journal's inaugural issue is devoted to the topic Critical Analysis of Law and the New Interdisciplinarity. The issue features papers from an international group of contributors not only from law, but also from other disciplines. It aims to capture some of the diversity of approaches to engaging with law as a discipline, and to locate within these projects the conception of bilateral interdisciplinarity in and on law that drives CAL.
Articles
- Pluralism and Empire: From Rome to Robert Cover, Clifford Ando - PDF
- The Interdisciplinary Party, Hanoch Dagan, Roy Kreitner - PDF
- Why Constitutionalism Matters: The Case for Robust Constitutionalism, Alon Harel - PDF
- Between a Rock and a Hard Place: Legal Studies Beyond Both Disciplinarity and Interdisciplinary, Mariana Valverde - PDF
- Law as Language, Marianne Constable - PDF
- Law and Interdisciplinarity: On the Inevitable Normativity of Legal Studies, Jan M. Smits - PDF
- A Narratology of the Law? Narratives in Legal Discourse, Monika Fludernik - PDF
- Authority in the Archives, Paul Halliday - PDF
The New Historical Jurisprudence issue highlights and encourages a trend in recent legal scholarship, or rather scholarship on law, that--like the original historical jurisprudence--pursues a historical analysis of law, as a form of critical analysis of law, rather than legal history, as applied historiography. Generated by theorists with a historical sensibility, and historians with theoretical curiosity, this emerging body of work exploits and challenges the intersection of history and jurisprudence in innovative and exciting ways.
Articles
- New Historical Jurisprudence: Legal History as Critical Analysis of Law, Markus D. Dubber - PDF
- On the Coloniality of Modern Law, Samera Esmeir - PDF
- Radbruch’s Rechtsstaat and Schmitt’s Legal Order: Legalism, Legality, and the Institution of Law, Mireille Hildebrandt - PDF
- The Judicialization of Police, Aaron T. Knapp - PDF
- Transatlantic Functionalism: New Deal Models and European Integration, Peter L. Lindseth - PDF
- “Society Owes Them Much”: Veteran Defendants and Criminal Responsibility in Australia in the Twentieth Century, Arlie Loughnan - PDF
- Private Law Codification, Modernization and Nationalism: A View from Critical Legal History, Heikki Pihlajamäki - PDF
- “Comparing” Jewish and Islamic Legal Traditions: Between Disciplinarity and Critical Historical Jurisprudence, Lena Salaymeh - PDF
- The Riddle of Sub-judice and the Modern Law of Contempt, Galia Schneebaum, Shai J. Lavi - PDF
- Regarding Untimeliness: Medieval Legal History and Modern Law, Karl Shoemaker - PDF
- The Rejection of Horizontal Judicial Review During America’s Colonial Period, Robert J. Seinfeld - PDF
Forthcoming Issue: Vol 3, No 2 (fall 2016)
3:2 will include a special issue on Regime Change: Orders of Law and Legal Transition, guest edited by Norman Spaulding (Stanford, Law). - More...
Forthcoming Issue: Vol 3, No 1 (spring 2016)
The spring 2016 CAL issue will feature a special issue on The New Ancient Legal History, guest edited by Clifford Ando (Chicago, Classics, History & Law). - More...
Contact
- Critical Analysis of Law, ℅ Nancy Bueler, University of Toronto, Faculty of Law, 84 Queen's Park, Toronto, Ontario M5S 2C5, Canada - http://cal.library.utoronto.ca/ - N. Bueler: nancy.bueler@utoronto.ca / S. Xiao Zhao: jps@library.utoronto.ca
Informations
Editorial Team
Editors-in-Chief
- Markus Dubber, University of Toronto, Law & Criminology
- Simon Stern, University of Toronto, Law & English
Editorial Board
- Clifford Ando, University of Chicago, Classics, History & Law
- Alan Brudner, University of Toronto, Law & Political Science
- Marianne Constable, University of California at Berkeley, Rhetoric
- Jeannine DeLombard, University of California at Santa Barbara, English
- Lindsay Farmer, University of Glasgow, Law
- Bernard Harcourt, Columbia University, Law
- Mireille Hildebrandt, Rotterdam/Nijmegen, Law/Computing & Information Sciences
- Karen Knop, University of Toronto, Law
- Shai Lavi, Tel Aviv University, Law & Ethics
- Bernadette Meyler, Stanford University, Law & English
- Heikki Pihlajamäki, University of Helsinki, Law
- Mariana Valverde, University of Toronto, Criminology & Sociolegal Studies
- Victoria Wohl, University of Toronto, Classics
- Mikhail Xifaras, Paris Sciences-Po, Law
Senior Editors
- Spencer Bass
- Maya Bielinski, Executive Editor
- Deborah Boswell
- Joseph Bricker
- Madeleine Burkhardt-Jones
- Joshua Freedman
- Jadine Lannon
- Olivia Lifman
- Ila Mada
- William McMillan
- Kathryn Palumbo
- Katya Popoff
- Dragana Rakic
- Evan Rosevear, Executive Editor
- Scarlett Smith
- Sharif Youssef
Administrative Assistant
- Nancy Bueler
Source: http://cal.library.utoronto.ca/